Flaming Pie, Paul McCartney’s 10th solo album, arrived on the tail finish of the Beatles’ mid-’90s renaissance. The remaining Fab 4 members instigated this revival with the discharge of their long-gestating documentary The Lengthy And Winding Highway, which was given the generic title Anthology by the point it ballooned right into a multi-media retrospective in 1995. As a consequence of a stroke of luck, the discharge of the documentary and its accompanying rarities compilations coincided with the rise of Britpop. The time was ripe for McCartney to ship an album steeped in Beatles lore, and that’s precisely what he claimed Flaming Pie was.
Upon its launch in Might 1997, McCartney maintained that his immersion within the Beatles’ previous impressed him to up his sport, to make an album within the vein of his previous band. Even its title was a nod to an arcane little bit of Fab 4 lore, derived from Lennon’s declare that he had a imaginative and prescient of a person on a flaming pie declaring that his band would henceforth be referred to as ”Beatles with an ’a’.” It was a canny advertising and marketing technique, a tacit acknowledgment that maybe his latest albums weren’t fairly as much as snuff whereas additionally snagging listeners whose curiosity within the Beatles might have been rejuvenated due to Anthology and the brand new breed of Britpoppers. It additionally was a bit misleading. Flaming Pie sounds as just like the Beatles as Oasis, which is to say not a lot in any respect; it’s recognizably in the identical melodic vein, however all of the manufacturing frills don’t recall Sgt. Pepper’s and the tone of the album is decidedly reflective, suiting a person taking inventory of his life upon the cusp of his 55th birthday.
Again in 1997, this wistful undercurrent was criticized as solipsistic—within the authentic overview for Rolling Stone, Anthony DeCurtis dismissed the album opener “The Music We Had been Singing” as a self-congratulatory “boomer memory”—however a dive into the rarities-laden Archive Version of Flaming Pie reveals that the album represented the tip of an period in addition to a inventive rebirth. In keeping with McCartney, he was instructed he couldn’t launch his solo album whereas the Anthology rollout was underway, so he saved tinkering with the songs that will comprise Flaming Pie whereas engaged on different initiatives—Standing Stone, his second long-form classical piece, for instance, and a reasonably tedious 1996 single known as “The Ballad of the Skeletons” during which he jammed with avant-garde icons Lenny Kaye, Philip Glass, and Marc Ribot.
Elsewhere, he sat for the interviews that shaped the guts of Barry Miles’ licensed 1997 biography Many Years From Now and spent a bit of 1995 dwelling out his DJ fantasies by way of the Westwood One radio present Oobu Joobu, whose 15 episodes had been condensed and edited into six B-sides for numerous Flaming Pie singles. He tagged alongside along with his spouse Linda each time she promoted her line of vegetarian meals and cookbooks, generally stealing away to write down a brand new track.
All of this exercise fed into Flaming Pie, whose origins are extra piecemeal than the completed mission suggests. Trawling by way of his again pages led to pulling two songs from his archives: the melodramatic pomp of “Stunning Night time,” which he tried with Billy Joel’s band in 1986, and “Nice Day,” which dated all the way in which again to the early ’70s, sharing a partial melody with “Large Barn Mattress” from Pink Rose Speedway. A few free blues rockers lower along with his previous buddy Steve Miller again in 1995 (“If You Wanna,” “Used To Be Unhealthy”) had been short-listed together with a pair of unreleased George Martin-produced outtakes from 1992 (“Calico Skies,” “Nice Day”) after which he enlisted the companies of Jeff Lynne, the Electrical Gentle Orchestra chief who shepherded the 2 “Threetles” Beatles reunion tracks for Anthology.
After the primary solo session with Lynne, the McCartneys acquired dangerous information: Linda had breast most cancers. Paul determined to hold on and full the album as a result of “the factor about these moments in life is, there’s no choice however to get on with it, ‘trigger the opposite choice can be to simply lie down and fall asleep, which isn’t an choice. So that you’ve simply bought to get on with it, you’ve bought to do issues, you’ve bought to go to the docs, preserve the factor going, preserve operating the store. You get on with it, and that is me getting on with it.” He wound up writing two songs after Linda’s prognosis, neither of that are heavy with grief. “Actually Love You” grew out of a cool jam with Ringo Starr, and “Heaven on a Sunday,” a lazy slice of jazzy yacht-rock, solely hints at his love for Linda by way of its chorus “If I solely had one love, yours can be the one I select.” Comparatively, the fragile finger-picked “Calico Skies” and “Little Willow” are infused with a way of loss and mourning, floating alongside upon a bittersweet breeze that neatly enhances the sepia-toned reflections of “The Music We Had been Singing” and “Somedays.”
These sweetly unhappy songs are those that linger, they usually’re served properly by their earliest incarnations as residence recordings and demos that function bonus tracks on each the double-disc reissue and companion 5-CD/2-DVD version. As good as it’s to listen to these hushed, unadorned tough variations, McCartney feels most comfy when he’s crafting an leisure, which Flaming Pie definitely is. Perhaps they don’t sound just like the Beatles, however with their stainless-steel gleam, “The World Tonight” and “Younger Boy” had been ornate singles designed to seize consideration whether or not heard on VH1, grownup up to date radio, or the soundtrack to the forgettable Robin Williams & Billy Crystal comedy Fathers’ Day. The informal however tangible chemistry between McCartney and Miller could also be in service of featherweight compositions, however they made the ultimate lower as a substitute of the extra attention-grabbing throwaways “Broomstick” and “Trying For You”—B-sides each, offered and accounted for on the reissue—as a result of the easy-rolling guitar duels supply some welcome air among the many album’s heavier numbers. Individually, they really feel skinny, however they assist make an album that captures a number of sides of McCartney’s character, a document the place his craft, silliness, sentiment, and allure are in stability.
Perhaps McCartney achieved that delicate equilibrium on Flaming Pie as a result of he was certainly “getting on with it,” coming to phrases along with his spouse’s sickness by making an album that celebrated these he held dearest. He’d proceed to play with Ringo for a lot of, many extra years, and he’d work with longtime engineer Geoff Emerick some time longer, however Flaming Pie can be the final time Linda sang on one in all his information, the final time George Martin wrote him an orchestration. It was additionally the primary time he discovered house for his son James on a document, giving him the guitar solo on “Heaven on a Sunday,” a gesture that gained poignancy through the years. Most significantly, Flaming Pie gave McCartney his first US High 10 album in 15 years, giving him the arrogance to strive newer and weirder issues as he headed into the brand new century. A few of these albums had been good, some had been dangerous, however none of them had the identical coronary heart as Flaming Pie. It might have its flaws, nevertheless it’s one of many uncommon McCartney albums the place he grapples with feelings too huge to neatly match contained in the confines of a pop document.
Catch up each Saturday with 10 of our best-reviewed albums of the week. Join the 10 to Hear e-newsletter right here.
Purchase: Tough Commerce
(Pitchfork earns a fee from purchases made by way of affiliate hyperlinks on our web site.)