Warning: This story comprises spoilers for the film Final Christmas.

When the primary trailer for Final Christmas dropped in August, many Twitter customers speculated that there could be a twist. And people web sleuths have been proper.

The vacation film stars Emilia Clarke as Kate, a 20-something Londoner for whom nothing appears to go proper. However the whole lot adjustments when she meets Tom (Henry Golding), a dreamy however mysterious man who pressures her to go on a date. Tom works nights, volunteers at a homeless shelter and doesn’t have a cellphone (or a minimum of, he’s locked it in his cabinet).

Emma Thompson, who co-wrote the screenplay with Bryony Kimmings and the story with husband Greg Smart, performs Kate’s immigrant mom. Rounding out the forged is Michelle Yeoh, Golding’s Loopy Wealthy Asians co-star, as Kate’s boss, who known as Santa, at a Christmas store. (Kate should put on an elf uniform whereas Yeoh’s character wears no matter she desires.)

Final Christmas, which is directed by Bridesmaids’ Paul Feig and contains a soundtrack of George Michael music, premieres Nov. 8. For many who haven’t seen the film and want to keep away from studying the fates of Kate and Tom, please bookmark this story, head to the theater and are available again later. However for these prepared to speak about what simply occurred, learn on for a radical accounting of all of the clues that led as much as that last Final Christmas twist.

Explaining the Final Christmas twist

(from left) Tom (Henry Golding) and Kate (Emilia Clarke) in  Last Christmas,  directed by Paul Feig.

(from left) Tom (Henry Golding) and Kate (Emilia Clarke) in “Final Christmas,” directed by Paul Feig.

Common Footage

Lots of the guesses on Twitter have been proper, in spite of everything. Tom died in a biking accident final Christmas, shortly after which Kate, who wanted a coronary heart transplant, acquired his coronary heart. Of their last scene collectively, after Kate learns the reality, Tom says that she was “all the time going to have my coronary heart,” a method or one other. Reader, I cried!

So, sure, all through the film, Kate was truly traipsing round London alone, speaking to herself and even ice skating by herself. (And breaking into an deserted house by herself, however extra on that later.)

If this was your guess from the beginning, congratulations!

Nevertheless, it stays unclear whether or not Tom is a ghost or only a figment of Kate’s creativeness. TIME has compiled the small print that paved the way in which for the movie’s twist, in addition to the plot holes and moments of misdirection that appear to muddle it.

Right here have been all of the hints to the massive twist in Final Christmas.

“Final Christmas” is Kate’s favourite music

In hindsight, the film’s title is a useless giveaway. Whereas viewers are led to guess that the film known as Final Christmas as a result of Kate repeatedly says it’s her favourite music (and it performs a minimum of thrice from totally different toys within the Christmas store), the twist reveals the title’s true which means — and the importance of the music being Kate’s favourite. “Final Christmas, I gave you my coronary heart,” is actually the precise plot.

Tom actually avoids working into folks

Early on within the film, as soon as Kate agrees to exit with Tom following his relentless strain (together with exhibiting up at her work after she’s already rejected him, which feels greater than a bit aggressive), she marvels at one thing unusual about him: He does a goofy, crazy dance maneuver as they stroll down the road. Why, she asks (and so can we), is he so bizarre? It’s solely as soon as the reality comes out that this lastly is smart — he’s doing the whole lot he can to keep away from working into folks, since he’s not truly bodily current. Had he by chance ran into somebody, would they’ve walked proper by way of him? We by no means get a solution, as he manages to efficiently keep away from contact.

Kate is the one one that ever speaks to or interacts with Tom

Whereas different characters like Santa and Kate’s associates know that Tom exists, none of them ever meet him in individual. Whereas that’s not notably putting at first as a result of he “works nights” and exhibits up unannounced, he does enter the Christmas store — it simply solely occurs within the scenes when Santa shouldn’t be there. It’s solely when she’s alone that he finds her.

No person on the homeless shelter acknowledges Tom’s title

When Kate goes to seek out Tom on the homeless shelter, no person has heard of him. Whereas it’s plausible that the volunteers through the evenings wouldn’t know the in a single day employees, this can be very unlikely that not one of the patrons — who’re just about all the time round, as Kate involves know them nicely as she continues volunteering — would have met him. (Except he has been useless for a 12 months, after all. In that case, it’s fairly believable that they wouldn’t know him.)

Kate all the time finds him when he’s on his bike

Tom is nearly all the time on his bike when Kate finds him. Not each single time, however fairly continuously. After studying the twist, this makes excellent sense. He was on his bike when he died a 12 months in the past, making it affordable that her conjuring of him usually locations him within the final place he assumed when he was alive.

Tom doesn’t put on a helmet

Tom by no means wears a helmet whereas using his bike. This isn’t exceptional at first — a suave 20-something in London may forego protecting gear — however within the flashback to his bike accident, he is sporting one. He isn’t sporting a helmet now, with Kate, as a result of he’s already useless. He doesn’t want to remain protected on the highway.

Tom’s “search for” quote

Tom all the time tells Kate to “search for” and see the wonders that London has to supply. Whereas educating Kate to concentrate to the sweetness that surrounds her (and focus much less on the negatives), he additionally could also be subtly educating her to look as much as the sky to seek out him in heaven.

We by no means discover out something about Tom’s life

Kate tells Tom just about the whole lot about her personal life, however he by no means reveals something about his household, his job or the place he lives. When he brings Kate residence to his house one evening, it’s freakishly neat, and appears as if no person presently lives in it. He doesn’t clarify why it’s so clear. (Kate later learns that’s as a result of it’s presently available on the market, as its proprietor, Tom, has died.)

Tom is the one character we see Kate discuss to about her coronary heart transplant

At “his” house, Kate tells Tom (and the viewer) about her mysterious sickness. Final Christmas, she had a coronary heart transplant, and he or she hasn’t felt like herself since. Tom touches the scar on her chest, and he or she tells him that being with him makes her really feel complete once more. He doesn’t need to be intimate along with her — the explanation for which isn’t actually defined — however they do find yourself kissing.

Tom doesn’t eat or sleep

When Kate wakes up in Tom’s house, she is happier than ever after making out with Tom. However he’s nowhere to be discovered. In truth, when she fell asleep the evening earlier than, he didn’t lay in mattress along with her, however put her to sleep alone, in a small mattress. So it appears as if he didn’t sleep that evening, and disappeared proper as she felt “complete” once more. Moreover, Tom by no means eats through the film, although different characters are seen consuming fairly continuously. Earlier than their romantic ice skating scene, Kate is consuming avenue meals on a bench, whereas Tom eats nothing.

However what about these plot holes?

Jonathan Prime—Common Footage

Whereas a lot of the unusual facets of Tom’s character are simply defined as soon as the twist is revealed, just a few issues by no means fairly add up.

Tom had by no means heard of Frozen

When Kate says she’s auditioning for a task in Frozen on Ice, he says he’s by no means heard of the now iconic Disney animated musical. That may make sense, if the film hadn’t come out in 2013. He had almost two full years to see the film (or a minimum of hear that it existed) earlier than he died. Maybe he was merely not maintaining with the Mouse Home, however “Let It Go” was just about unavoidable for fairly a while after that film’s launch.

How do they kiss?

No person is complaining a couple of Henry Golding-Emilia Clarke smooching scene, however it does beg the query: If Tom can’t be intimate with Kate, and he can’t even run into folks on the road, why can he make out along with her? A very good vacation rom-com could have felt incomplete with out it, however we’re nonetheless scratching our heads.

Write to Rachel E. Greenspan at rachel.greenspan@time.com.

Supply hyperlink

Welcome my dear !
Do you want listen a brand new SAD LOVE SONG ?